Gary Tucker was attending a conference on monkeys used in medical research when he spotted some uninvited guests: agents with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
As they walked in and out of the Colorado hotel, Tucker, an executive at a monkey import company, hid in the lobby to spy on them, according to federal prosecutors.
He had good reason to be wary. The agents were investigating whether Tucker’s company, BioOrient Resource Center, and its competitors were involved in an international monkey smuggling scheme in which endangered primates were being pulled from the wild and shipped to the U.S. for use by government researchers and pharmaceutical companies.
Tucker’s actions that day in October 2019 included taking photos of the agents and urging people at the conference not to talk to them, according to prosecutors who have been working with wildlife officials to crack down on an industry that plays a critical role in drug and vaccine development but largely operates in secrecy.
“It’s a dirty business, and it’s extremely difficult to get to the bottom of,” said Ed Newcomer, a former U.S. Fish and Wildlife agent who investigated monkey importers and exporters in the U.S. and southeast Asia during his 20 years with the agency.
Tucker, 65, pleaded guilty last year to lying to federal agents about the company’s operations in Cambodia.
Just last month, the Justice Department charged eight people, including two Cambodian wildlife officials, with conspiring to poach monkeys from the wild and send them to the U.S. with falsified paperwork claiming that they came from breeding centres.
But the cases represent only the tip of the iceberg, according to former wildlife agents.
The smuggling of wild-caught monkeys is believed to have been going on for years due to the colossal demand for laboratory monkeys in the U.S. and the limited supply at breeding facilities at home and abroad. The arrival of the pandemic and the race to find a vaccine squeezed the market even further, experts say, setting off a mad scramble for the animals that fueled a spike in monkey poaching and contributed to the endangerment of the species most commonly used in drug studies – the long-tailed macaque.
“It’s gotten out of hand,” said Melane Friis Hansen, director of the Long-tailed Macaque Project, a Denmark-based nonprofit focused. “The insane demand coming from the U.S. is driving the trade to an insane level.”
A booming business
The U.S. leads the world in the number of primates it imports for medical research. Between 2017 and May 2022, more than 150,000 monkeys arrived in the U.S. to be used in experiments, according to figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Researchers say monkeys have been crucial to understanding different types of conditions, from AIDS to Parkinson’s Disease, as well as ensuring the safety and efficacy of new drugs.
China was long the main supplier of primates to the U.S., but it banned the sale of wildlife at the start of the pandemic in March 2020. The move upended the international trade in monkeys at a time when research facilities needed them more than ever for future vaccine trials.
With demand soaring, the price of monkeys skyrocketed. A single long-tailed macaque could fetch $40,000 at the height of the pandemic – up from $3,000 just a couple years prior.
“It’s inconceivable to me how high it went,” said Greg Westergaard, the founder and CEO of Alpha Genesis, a South Carolina-based company that breeds and sources monkeys for pharmaceutical companies and government researchers.
With China out of the game, countries like Mauritius and Cambodia stepped in.
Cambodia is home to a number of macaque breeding farms, but they receive little scrutiny and the paperwork that accompanies monkeys imported to the U.S. is easy to fudge – a dynamic that makes it nearly impossible to ensure that the animals are in fact bred in captivity, experts say.
This species will be going extinct or functionally extinct by the end of the 21st century if we don’t change anything right now”
Agustin Fuentes, primatologist, Princeton University
It wasn’t long before conservationists began noticing an increase in reports of monkeys being pulled out of the wild by poachers in Southeast Asia lured by the huge profits at stake.
“These guys know what they’re doing,” said Edwin Wiek, founder of the Wildlife Friends Foundation Thailand, an animal rescue group. “They’re not just going out there and taking whatever they can catch. They’re really trying to take the cherries off the cake.”
In 2019, Cambodia supplied 8,571 of the 33,818 research monkeys imported to the U.S., or 25%. In 2021, the number of monkeys from Cambodia more than doubled to 18,870, making up nearly 60% of the 31,844 research monkeys brought to the U.S.
The dramatic increase has led some experts to question whether Cambodia’s breeding farms are actually capable of producing that many monkeys.
A colony with 100 females of breeding age would produce at most 60 to 70 offspring in a given year, Westergaard said. He noted that it would take another two to three years for the babies to reach an age where they’re suitable for research.
“It takes a very long time to establish a good primate supply,” he said. “It’s not something that can be done in a hurry, and it cannot be done on the cheap.”
“You can imagine with that much financial incentive, you’re going to have all sorts of newcomers who are not in it for the long term and may not have a history of performing ethically,” Westergaard added.
But the trade has already had a significant impact on the populations of long-tailed macaques in the wild. In July, the International Union for Conservation of Nature changed their status from “vulnerable” to “endangered,” citing their use in medical testing as a driving force.
“This species will be going extinct or functionally extinct by the end of the 21st century if we don’t change anything right now,” said Agustin Fuentes, a Princeton University primatologist.
The upheaval in the monkey trade has also had other consequences.
Between 2019 and 2021, the number of monkeys found dead on arrival in the U.S. or that died within 30 days rose sharply – from 77 to 136 – despite there being 2,000 fewer imported monkeys overall, according to CDC data obtained by NBC News through a public records request.
It’s difficult to conclude what could be driving the increase, experts say, and the dead monkeys still account for less than 1% of those that arrive in this country.
But the escalating death figures provide more ammunition to animal rights groups and others who argue that the trade in research monkeys is cruel and inhumane – and poses a public health risk due to the threat of monkey-borne illnesses spreading to humans.
“When you take a macaque out of its natural habitat and you start channelling them down this pipeline towards the laboratories in the U.S. or the E.U., you’re setting off a change reaction for the potential for disease spillover and transmission,” said Lisa Jones-Engel, a former primatologist and researcher at the Washington National Primate Research Center who is now an adviser for the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, or PETA.
“It’s a recipe for the next pandemic.”
Investigative hurdles
The trade in long-tailed macaques is regulated by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, or CITES, a 1975 treaty designed to ensure that the global market for certain plants and animals doesn’t threaten their survival in the wild.
CITES determines, for instance, how many protected animals a country is allowed to export. It can also bar a country from exporting animals like long-tailed macaques, as it did for Laos in 2016 after investigations found that traders there were selling wild-caught monkeys to dealers in China, Vietnam and Cambodia who were exporting the animals to other countries falsely labelled as originating in their own.
Cambodia has faced accusations of “monkey laundering” for a number of years now. In 2015, a research arm of CITES called the Species for Survival Network submitted a document to the convention that said field investigations in Cambodia found that long-tailed macaques were being trapped without permits in two provinces and transferred to breeding farms.
“To avoid detection by the authorities, the animals were reportedly brought into the farms during the night, hidden under packs of ice in vehicles which had been adapted to hold cages,” the document says.
Before monkeys are shipped from overseas, the import company in the U.S. must complete a Fish and Wildlife declaration form and a CITES permit, which is issued by the exporting country.
But there’s often little vetting done in the countries where monkeys are coming from, experts say, so the paperwork isn’t especially reliable. Compounding the problem, the breeding farms that are said to be producing the monkeys aren’t closely scrutinised in places like Cambodia, experts say.
The Fish and Wildlife Service has been concerned about the industry for years, former agents told NBC News, but efforts to investigate it have been stymied repeatedly.
There is the problem of weak wildlife enforcement overseas. But U.S. wildlife officers face another challenge: The companies that import and export monkeys are notoriously insular and suspicious of outsiders, making it highly difficult for law enforcement to develop the kind of contacts and evidence necessary to prove that company officials imported monkeys they knew were caught in the wild.
Newcomer, the retired agent, said he realised how difficult it would be in building a case against monkey import companies when he was tasked with developing sources at an industry event many years ago.
“I had to have a tighter undercover persona for that one event than I had to work with gang members in South [Los Angeles] who would kill me if they knew who I was,” Newcomer said.
Craig Tabor, a former Fish and Wildlife agent who retired last year, said he looked into monkey laundering allegations more than a decade ago, but the investigation was ultimately dropped due in part to concerns about whether wildlife officials overseas could be trusted.
“We’d be dealing with unknown players in foreign governments, many of whom are very corrupt,” Tabor said. “We had no way of knowing who had been paid off by illegal actors to help facilitate getting these animals out of the country of origin and into the U.S.”
One of the Cambodian officials charged in the indictment unsealed last month is accused of personally delivering wild-caught monkeys to a facility run by Vanny Resources Holdings, a Hong Kong-based company that breeds monkeys for research. The suspect, Masphal Kry, 46, who was arrested at John F. Kennedy International Airport, has not yet entered a plea, and his lawyer did not respond to a request for comment.
Two unidentified companies in the U.S. – one in Florida and one in Alice, Texas – imported hundreds of the wild-caught monkeys, according to the indictment, which referred to the companies as unindicted co-conspirators.
The tiny town of Alice was the home of Orient BioResource Center, the company where Gary Tucker was a vice president when he was charged with lying to federal agents.
In that case, Tucker admitted to falsely claiming that the company didn’t produce reports detailing the conditions of the breeding facilities in Cambodia and the numbers and characteristics of the monkeys held inside of them.
The reports would provide prosecutors with a “true picture of the various facilities, which it believes are in fact laundering and illegally marketing in the world market captured animals – animals taken illegally from the wild under the treaties and under U.S. law and sent to the U.S. with false documentation,” assistant U.S. attorney Thomas Watts-Fitzgerald said at Tucker’s sentencing in October 2021, according to a transcript of the hearing.
“And that’s what they’re all afraid of.”
Tucker, who was sentenced to three years of probation, did not respond to requests for comment.
Orient BioResource Center was purchased by another company, Inotiv, in November 2021. Inotiv has acknowledged that Orient and a second subsidiary, Envigo Global Services, were subpoenaed in the federal probe.
Earlier this week, the company announced that it is refraining from selling or delivering any of its Cambodian monkeys until they can be “reasonably determined to be purpose-bred.”
“Inotiv is fully cooperating with the ongoing federal investigation concerning the importation of non-human primates,” a spokesperson said in response to a request from NBC News. “Gary Tucker left Orient BioResource Center in connection with Inotiv’s acquisition of such company, and has never been an Inotiv employee.”
The south Florida company described as an unindicted co-conspirator in the indictment may be Worldwide Primates, based in Miami.
Of the 21 registered monkey import companies in the U.S., WorldWide Primates is the only one based in the jurisdiction of the U.S. attorney for the southern district of Florida, according to a CDC document obtained by NBC News through a public records request
WorldWide Primates did not return calls seeking comment.
Tracking monkey shipments
The monkey shortage spurred by China’s export ban has prompted some American scientists to call for a new effort to boost the country’s domestic supply of primates for research.
The U.S. government operates seven primate centres that house about 21,000 macaques, baboons and other species.
Deborah Fuller, associate director of research at the Washington National Primate Research Center, said the role monkeys played in the development of Covid vaccines underscores how vital they are to drug research.
“I would say that our ability to have developed vaccines within a year, if it weren’t for non-human primates, we would still be sitting around waiting for a vaccine right now,” said Fuller.
The decades-long effort by animal rights groups to derail the monkey trade has made some impacts.
Facing opposition from activists, most passenger airlines have stopped transporting monkeys in recent years.
But the primates are still arriving in droves in cargo planes that land in major cities, where they are met by Fish and Wildlife inspectors in tyvek suits who look over paperwork but tend to perform only cursory inspections of the animals themselves, according to former agents.
The animals are then loaded into unmarked vans and driven to quarantine facilities that are sometimes hundreds of miles away. The monkeys must remain at the quarantine facilities for 30 days, where they are tested for a range of illnesses, including tuberculosis and Herpes B.
From the time they’re loaded onto a truck in their host countries to the time they arrive at quarantine facilities in the U.S., the monkeys can be in transit for well over a full day.
Sometimes accidents happen along the way.
Last March, a truck hauling monkeys from Kennedy Airport to a Missouri facility was struck by another vehicle on a Pennsylvania highway, sending several monkey crates onto the road.
Three monkeys escaped from their cages and bolted into the woods. They were later tracked down and shot dead by wildlife officers.
A motorist, Michele Fallon, unexpectedly came face-to-face with one of the caged monkeys after she stopped to check on the drivers in the crash. She wound up with pink eye-like symptoms that cleared up after a few days (It’s not clear if her symptoms were caused by the animals).
“I was in shock – I just couldn’t believe it was transporting monkeys,” said Fallon. “The cages did not say anything about there being dangerous animals inside or ones that you could get sick from.”
The incident shined a rare spotlight on the monkey trade, which largely goes on outside the view of the public.
“I don’t think we can underestimate the stress and the suffering that these animals are subjected to when they’re transported across these time zones, across different climates for up to 30 hours or so,” said Sarah Kite, co-founder of the animal rights group Action for Primates. “These are highly sensitive individual animals who have been confined and imprisoned in these small transit crates.”
Kite relies on a network of informants at airports in Southeast Asia and Europe to help her track flights of primates to the U.S. and elsewhere.
“Very little is made public about mortalities on board or injuries or illness or disease – that’s something that doesn’t reach the public domain,” Kite said.
Fuentes, the Princeton University primatologist, doesn’t advocate for a blanket ban against the use of monkeys for medical testing but he believes the industry needs to be brought out of the shadows.
“If this was totally above board and there were no illegal or otherwise shady dealings going on … then why is it so hard to find information about them,” Fuentes said.
Additional reporting by Sophanna Lay. Photos by Anton L. Delgado for Southeast Asia Globe.
This article was produced in collaboration with NBC, with the support of The Pulitzer Center’s Rainforest Investigations Network.
